Stalking Samantha: 13 Years of Terror
In 2009, Samantha Stites began a harrowing decade-long ordeal when Christopher Thomas, a man she had briefly interacted with in a Christian group, became obsessed with her. Despite repeated rejections, blocked messages, and a restraining order, Thomas escalated from stalking to kidnapping—building a soundproof bunker in a storage unit, tracking her vehicles, and holding her captive for two weeks. In 2024, after a failed personal protection order and a near-fatal confrontation, he was arrested and sentenced to 40 to 60 years in prison, with lifetime GPS monitoring. The case exposes systemic failures in protecting victims, the chilling reality of digital surveillance, and the psychological manipulation of a predator who weaponized media like the show *You* to justify his crimes. Samantha’s survival and resilience, coupled with the court’s rare, maximum sentence, mark a rare victory in a justice system that often fails survivors of prolonged stalking and sexual violence. The episode reveals how one man’s obsession, fueled by delusion and technological surveillance, could go unchecked for over a decade—despite clear warning signs, multiple restraining orders, and even a prior conviction. It underscores the emotional toll on victims who are forced to live in fear, constantly monitoring their surroundings, while the legal system repeatedly fails to act.
Christopher Thomas built a soundproof bunker in a storage unit using $5,000 from Menards, complete with metal rings and insulation, to hold Samantha captive for two weeks.
He used GPS trackers on Samantha’s car, her roommate’s car, and her friend’s car—replacing batteries every few weeks to maintain surveillance.
Despite a six-year personal protection order and a prior conviction, the court denied Samantha’s second PPO, citing a 'complicated relationship' and lack of specific facts.
Samantha survived by feigning consent to sex, using a handshake agreement to secure her release—proving that survival tactics in captivity are not signs of complicity.
The judge sentenced Thomas to 40 to 60 years—effectively a life sentence—because he was deemed irredeemable and a continued threat to public safety.
…and 3 more takeaways available in PodZeus
The Vanishing of Five Women: A Case That Never Cold
“The evidence is still there, and this case isn't cold. It's unfinished.”
The First Encounter: A Stalker’s Birth in Kindness
Samantha recounts her first meeting with Christopher in 2011, when he appeared friendly at a Christian group event. What began as a social interaction quickly turned into obsession after she politely declined his advances, a moment he twisted into a romantic narrative.
The Escalation: From Flowers to Fear
Christopher’s behavior escalates from unwanted gifts and messages to physical appearances at her workplace, apartment, and even her graduation. Samantha documents each encounter, realizing too late that she’s being stalked—only to face disbelief when seeking legal protection.
The Bunker: A Soundproof Prison Built from Obsession
“He built it himself and he kind of takes pride in building this structure.”
The Kidnapping: A Two-Week Nightmare
“I've taken vacation and we're going to spend some time together.”
“If somehow you are released at some point near future then it is a requirement that you will have a lifetime GPS so that we will know where you are.”
“The evidence is still there, and this case isn't cold. It's unfinished.”
“He says, I've taken vacation and we're going to spend some time together.”
Hosts
Guest
Samantha Stites
person
Christopher Thomas
person
Judge Elzenheimer
person
David Muir
person
Menards
brand
You (TV series)
media
Debra Roberts
person
Grand Traverse County Prosecutor
organization
Hulu
brand
ABC News
organization
The After Show: Stalking Samantha – 13 Years of Terror
24m • 6/15/2026
Jeffrey is getting a new car! Rover tries to weasel out of walking a marathon, & more
2h 55m • 6/1/2026
B&T Extra: Mowing, New Houses, & Dumpsters
19m • 6/2/2026
#617: 617|Teen Rapists Walk Free!
19m • 6/3/2026
How predictions took over our lives
49m • 6/12/2026
Start discovering podcast insights today
Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.
No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime

