The Snare: Peacekeeper
In 1996, 18-year-old Angie Dodge was brutally murdered in her Idaho Falls apartment, leaving behind a community in shock and a case that would remain unsolved for years. Despite a clean crime scene with no forced entry and a chilling lack of struggle, Detective Jeff Pratt noticed a disturbing anomaly: a void in the blood spatter pattern that suggested the killer may not have acted alone. Angie, described as a joyful, organized, and fiercely compassionate 'peacekeeper,' had recently moved into her own apartment and was on the cusp of independence—her first job, her first car, her first real taste of freedom. Just hours before her death, she reconciled with her mother, confessing she’d done something 'really stupid'—a secret that would haunt her family for decades. While police interviewed nearly 100 people and Carol Dodge launched her own investigation, no suspect emerged—until a shocking arrest in Nevada months later linked a man seen at Angie’s funeral to a similar crime. The case, once cold, was rekindled by a single thread: a man who knew her, who was there, and who vanished into thin air. The Snare isn’t just about a murder—it’s about the cost of silence, the weight of a single unspoken confession, and the terrifying possibility that justice was never about finding the killer… but about uncovering what Angie tried to hide.
Angie Dodge’s murder featured a blood spatter void suggesting possible co-perpetrators, challenging the lone-killer theory.
The victim’s final words—'I've done something really stupid'—remain a haunting, unsolved clue that may hold the key to her murder.
Carol Dodge, Angie’s mother, became a de facto detective, distributing 2,500 flyers and interviewing suspects in the drug scene.
A man arrested in Nevada for a similar crime was captured on video at Angie’s funeral, linking him to the case decades later.
Angie’s apartment had no forced entry, no signs of struggle, and was unusually clean—indicating the killer may have been known to her.
…and 3 more takeaways available in PodZeus
The Hook: A Story of Justice Unfinished
“The evidence is still there. And this case isn't cold. It's unfinished.”
The Vanishing Killer
Five women are abducted in a store, with a lone survivor describing the killer. Despite a clear description and nearly being caught, the suspect vanishes—setting the stage for a case that defies closure.
The Interrogation That Changed Everything
“I'll take a lie detector test. I will find anything that would just verify what I said.”
The Life of Angie Dodge
Through interviews with friends and family, the episode paints a vivid portrait of Angie as a joyful, organized, and compassionate young woman who had just begun to live independently.
The Crime Scene: A Clean but Violent Room
“I believe really early on would have severed the larynx and the voice box. I don't believe she could have screamed.”
“She says, you know, Mom, I've done something really stupid. And I said, sweetheart, we all do things stupid. Look at the stupid things that I've done.”
“The injury to Angie's throat, I believe really early on would have severed the larynx and the voice box. I don't believe she could have screamed.”
“There was an arrest hundreds of miles away in Nevada of a man who hung out down by the Snake River too. A man who knew Angie Dodge. A man who was even captured on video at Angie's funeral.”
Host
Guests
Angie Dodge
person
Idaho Falls
place
Carol Dodge
person
Detective Jeff Pratt
person
Tim Quick
person
Snake River
place
Chris Tapp
person
Jeremy Sargis
person
ABC Audio
organization
2020
organization
Start discovering podcast insights today
Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.
No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime

