True Confession
Carol Dodge, a mother devastated by her daughter Angie Dodge's brutal 1996 murder, spent over two decades chasing justice—only to realize the man convicted of the crime, Christopher Tapp, was innocent. After years of relentless investigation, DNA evidence and a groundbreaking use of genetic genealogy revealed that the real killer was Brian Dripps, a neighbor who had lived across the street from Angie’s apartment. Tapp, coerced into a false confession during intense, suggestive interrogations by detectives who believed he was guilty, had spent 20 years in prison. When the truth emerged, Carol Dodge became his fiercest advocate, helping to secure his exoneration—the first in the world achieved through genetic genealogy. But the story didn’t end with justice. Tapp, who had rebuilt his life and become an activist for the wrongfully convicted, died in 2023 under suspicious circumstances in Las Vegas. Authorities later ruled his death a homicide, charging former wrestler Daniel Rodimer. The case, once a tale of false confession and police overreach, became a tragic arc of redemption, loss, and unresolved violence—proving that even after truth is found, life can still be cruelly interrupted. The episode reveals how flawed interrogation tactics, confirmation bias, and the rush to conviction can destroy lives. It shows how one mother’s unwavering belief in justice, combined with modern forensic science, can overturn decades of error.
DNA evidence proved Christopher Tapp was not at the crime scene, making his 20-year prison sentence a false conviction based on coerced confessions.
Genetic genealogy, using a degraded DNA sample from the crime scene, led investigators to Brian Dripps—the real killer—after 25 years.
Detective Jared Furman’s suggestive interrogation tactics, including repeated polygraphs and hypothetical questions, created a false narrative that led Tapp to confess.
Carol Dodge, the victim’s mother, became the most powerful advocate for Tapp’s innocence, turning her grief into a mission to correct a systemic failure.
Tapp was exonerated in 2019, becoming the first person in history to be cleared via genetic genealogy, and received $11.7 million in compensation.
…and 3 more takeaways available in PodZeus
The Case That Changed Everything
Craig Melvin introduces the podcast, setting the tone for a story of truth, loss, and redemption. The episode begins with the emotional weight of Angie Dodge’s murder and the lifelong quest of her mother, Carol Dodge, to find justice.
The Murder of Angie Dodge
The crime scene is described in harrowing detail—Angie Dodge, 18, was nearly decapitated, her body posed, and a blood-soaked teddy bear found near her. The investigation begins with no weapon, no forced entry, and a growing sense of dread.
The False Confession
Christopher Tapp, a River Kid friend of Angie, is interrogated for 20 hours over nine sessions. Under pressure, he confesses to being involved in the murder, despite having no DNA at the scene. The police believe he’s guilty, but the truth is far more complex.
The DNA That Changed Everything
The semen found on Angie’s body doesn’t match Tapp or Ben Hobbs. The detectives are frustrated, but crime scene investigator Jeff Pratt insists DNA will solve the case. Carol Dodge, however, begins her own investigation.
Carol Dodge’s Obsession
Carol Dodge becomes obsessed with finding the real killer. She reads police reports, drives 60,000 miles searching for leads, and eventually discovers a lab report stating pubic hairs were “similar to the victim”—a clue that sparks her investigation.
“Furman, he said, hypothetically, even if you did cut her, it still ain't going to matter. We'll be able to help you.”
“Her words to me I'll never forget were I just want to know what happened to my daughter and uh you know it still brings the hair up on the back of my neck.”
“This is my last interview. I will never talk about the Edgy Dodge case again.”
Host
Guests
Carol Dodge
person
Christopher Tapp
person
Idaho Falls Police Department
organization
Brian Dripps
person
Jeremy Sarges
person
Jared Furman
person
Ken Brown
person
Russ Baldwin
person
Destiny Osborne
person
CeCe Moore
person
The Devil Wore White - Update
1h 22m • 6/2/2026
Talking Dateline: The Devil Wore White - Update
26m • 6/3/2026
A Killing in Midtown
41m • 6/9/2026
Talking Dateline: A Killing in Midtown
26m • 6/10/2026
Karen Read's bombshell lawsuit. Twist in Crystal Rogers case. Plus, Legally Brunette host Emily Simpson.
36m • 6/11/2026
Start discovering podcast insights today
Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.
No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime

