‘Schmigadoon!’ co-creator Cinco Paul satirizes Broadway

In this episode of Fresh Air, host David Bianculli interviews Cinco Paul, co-creator and songwriter of the hit musical Schmigadoon, which recently opened on Broadway to critical acclaim. Paul reflects on the origins of the idea—conceived 25 years ago after watching An American Werewolf in London and imagining a modern couple stumbling into a musical world like Brigadoon. He discusses how the show evolved from a six-part Apple TV+ series into a stage production, preserving its satirical spirit while condensing the story. Paul shares insights into the show’s comedic and heartfelt approach to parodying classic 1940s–50s musicals, including songs like 'Corn Puddin'' that mock clichéd musical moments such as picnic scenes. He also explores the show’s subtle but powerful commentary on queer representation in musical theater, particularly through the character of Mayor Menlove, whose secret gay identity is revealed through a lovingly crafted parody of classic 'secret love' songs. Paul reflects on his own journey—from a childhood obsessed with musicals and theater, to a career in animation with Despicable Me and The Secret Life of Pets, to finally returning to his roots in songwriting. He candidly discusses the lack of residuals for animation writers and the emotional weight of creating a musical that honors both his personal history and the legacy of the genre. The episode also features a review of the film Blue Heron by Sophie Romvari, a poignant, semi-autobiographical coming-of-age drama about family, memory, and mental illness.