MoNo Encore: The Revenge of Hannah Duston w/ Jay Atkinson
Get the full intelligence
Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “MoNo Encore: The Revenge of Hannah Duston w/ Jay Atkinson” inside PodZeus.
In this Most Notorious Encore episode, host Eric Rivenis revisits the controversial 1697 story of Hannah Dustin with historian Jay Atkinson, author of *Massacre on the Merrimack*. The episode delves into the brutal raid on Haverhill, Massachusetts, where a group of Abenaki warriors killed 27 colonists, including Dustin’s infant daughter, and took 13 captives. Atkinson recounts how Dustin, a 39-year-old mother of ten, survived a two-week forced march through the frozen wilderness, forged a bond with a young captive named Sam Lennerson, and orchestrated a bloody revenge by killing 13 of her captors—including women and children—on Sugarball Island. The narrative explores the moral ambiguity of her actions, the trauma inflicted on both sides, and the lasting cultural and political tensions surrounding her legacy. Atkinson emphasizes the complexity of colonial frontier life, the shared history of displacement, and the ongoing debate over how history is remembered, particularly through monuments like the controversial statue of Dustin holding a hatchet and scalps. The episode concludes with a call for reconciliation through inclusive storytelling, acknowledging both the Puritan and Abenaki perspectives.
Hannah Dustin’s survival and revenge were driven by desperation, trauma, and the harsh calculus of frontier life.
The story of Hannah Dustin is not just about one woman’s act of vengeance but a microcosm of colonial violence, cultural erasure, and contested memory.
The Abenaki version of the story, preserved through oral tradition, challenges the sanitized, heroic narrative promoted by white settlers.
Monuments and public memory are battlegrounds—Haverhill’s statue of Dustin has been altered to downplay violence, reflecting modern discomfort with historical heroism.
True historical understanding requires engaging with multiple perspectives, not just one side of the story.
…and 3 more takeaways available in PodZeus
Introduction to the Encore Episode
Eric Rivenis introduces the encore episode, revisiting the 2017 story of Hannah Dustin with guest Jay Atkinson. He highlights the emotional and cultural resonance of the story, noting its lasting impact on both descendants and Indigenous communities.
The Raid on Haverhill: March 15, 1697
Atkinson describes the surprise attack by Tarentine warriors on Haverhill, detailing how they burned homes, killed 27 people, and captured 13, including Hannah Dustin. He emphasizes the strategic precision and terror of the raid.
Thomas Dustin’s Escape and the Children’s Survival
Thomas Dustin, a veteran of King Philip’s War, races back to save his seven surviving children, leading them to safety on horseback just before the raiders arrive. His actions set the stage for Hannah’s later survival.
Hannah Dustin’s Captivity and the Murder of Her Infant
Atkinson recounts the harrowing journey north, including the brutal murder of Hannah’s newborn daughter by an Indian warrior. This moment marks a turning point in her resolve to survive and seek revenge.
The Role of Sam Lennerson: A Young Captive’s Crucial Help
Atkinson details how Sam Lennerson, a 14-year-old white captive adopted by the Abenaki, becomes a key ally. He learns the warriors’ tactics and helps Hannah plan her escape and massacre.
“They should take that statue down and they should repatriate the land to the Pinnacook. It should be ours. It shouldn't be partially owned by Boston and Maine Railroad because now a bridge goes over the island.”
“The more I think about it, I do tend to feel more sympathetic for the Native American tribes... but on the other hand, if someone harmed my child, I would take some kind of action against them.”
“The more I think about it, I do tend to feel more sympathetic for the Native American tribes, not just the ones that were affected by Hannah Dustin's actions, but the ones that were living in the region. They got lied to repeatedly and then eventually got driven north or extinguished.”
Host
Guest
Hannah Dustin
person
Jay Atkinson
person
Abenaki
other
Haverhill, Massachusetts
place
Merrimack River
place
Thomas Dustin
person
Pinnacook
other
Sam Lennerson
person
Cotton Mather
person
Sugarball Island
place
432: Chicago's Apartment 131 Murders w/ Gregg Owen
Most Notorious! A True Crime History Podcast • 1h 26m • 4/3/2026
433: Julia Bulette: Murdered by a Serial Killer? w/ Robin Flinchum
Most Notorious! A True Crime History Podcast • 1h 31m • 4/9/2026
434: The Murders That Inspired Lincoln's Lyceum Address w/ Saladin Ambar
Most Notorious! A True Crime History Podcast • 1h 5m • 4/18/2026
Get the full intelligence
Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “MoNo Encore: The Revenge of Hannah Duston w/ Jay Atkinson” inside PodZeus.
Start discovering podcast insights today
Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.
No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime