When He Swore an Oath, It Wasn’t to a Political Party. (w/ Seth Bodnar)

The Bulwark12mJune 7, 2026
AI-Generated Summary

The United States has reached a moral and political crisis, according to Seth Bodnar, a former university president and Green Beret running as an independent for Montana’s U.S. Senate seat. He argues that the country’s deep polarization—evidenced by a Pew Research survey showing Americans are the least likely to believe their fellow citizens are good and moral—threatens democracy itself. Bodnar, who swore an oath to the Constitution, not a political party, rejects both major parties as broken and unrepresentative of rural America. He points to Republican disenfranchisement tactics, like Steve Daines withdrawing from a race to block rivals, and Democratic neglect of rural voters, citing Chuck Schumer’s infamous comment about trading rural losses for suburban gains. Bodnar insists that Montanans are tired of being used and divided. His campaign is not a vanity project but a response to a system that rewards loyalty over service. He believes that by focusing on mission over party, he can deliver real results for all Montanans—without being beholden to party bosses or special interests.

Key Takeaways
1

The U.S. ranks dead last among 25 countries in public trust in fellow citizens, a sign of democratic decay.

2

Bodnar’s oath was to the Constitution, not a political party—making independence authentic to his values.

3

Republicans have disenfranchised Montanans by blocking competition in elections, undermining democratic participation.

4

Democrats have strategically abandoned rural voters, treating them as expendable for suburban gains.

5

Montanans are hungry for leaders who prioritize mission over party loyalty and work across the aisle.

…and 3 more takeaways available in PodZeus

Chapters
0:00
1 min

The Crisis of Trust in America

You know which country finished dead last on that survey in terms of the percent that said their fellow countrymen were good and moral people? The United States of America.

Highlight
1:00
2 min

Why Bodnar Chose Independence

Bodnar explains his decision to run as an independent, rooted in his military oath to the Constitution and a lifelong focus on mission over party.

2:30
3 min

The Failure of Both Major Parties

Republicans think, Hey, if there's an R by my name, I'm just going to win whether I show up and work for you or not.

Highlight
5:00
3 min

The Broken Democratic Brand in Montana

Bodnar details how Democratic leaders like Chuck Schumer have publicly dismissed rural voters, making the party unappealing in states like Montana.

7:30
3 min

The Real Cost of Partisan Toxicity

46% increase in farm bankruptcies last year relative to the year before. Farmers are in crisis, rural healthcare is in crisis.

Highlight
High-Impact Quotes
You know which country finished dead last on that survey in terms of the percent that said their fellow countrymen were good and moral people? The United States of America.
Seth Bodnar0:10
You know, at the age of 18, I swore an oath to the Constitution of the United States. And I didn't swear loyalty to a political party.
Seth Bodnar3:14
We finished behind Nigeria. That's a kill shot to a democratic republic.
Seth Bodnar10:49
Speakers

Host

John Adlon

Guest

Seth Bodnar
Topics Discussed
montana senate race95%political polarization90%trust in government88%partisan toxicity87%independent candidates85%rural america crisis80%congress approval ratings75%george washington farewell address70%
People & Brands

Seth Bodnar

person

18xPositive

John Adlon

person

5xNeutral

Chuck Schumer

person

2xNegative

George Washington

person

2xPositive

Steve Daines

person

2xNegative

John Tester

person

2xNeutral

Pew Research

organization

2xNeutral

South Africa

place

1xNeutral

Bernie Sanders

person

1xNeutral

Angus King

person

1xNeutral

Start discovering podcast insights today

Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.

No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime