Lived Once, Buried Twice (PODCAST EXCLUSIVE EPISODE)
In a chilling trio of true stories, MrBallen reveals how the line between life and death is often thinner than we imagine. The first tale centers on Alice Knott, a reclusive student whose death from gas poisoning was caused not by human malice but by her beloved parrot, Polly—whose habit of inhaling gas to get high led to a fatal buildup in her room. The second story follows obstetrician Linda Gowdy, whose premonition of dying in a car crash on a Caribbean cruise led her to cancel the trip—only to be murdered in her own car days later, a tragedy her boyfriend Tim Stryker would later be convicted of perjury over. The final and most haunting story is about John McCall, who buried his wife Marjorie after she died of fever, only to open his door days later and see her—alive, missing a finger, and covered in dirt—after grave robbers cut it off to steal her wedding ring. The shock of seeing her resurrected from the grave caused John to suffer a fatal heart attack. The episode closes with the real headstone at Shankill Cemetery: 'Lived Once, Buried Twice.' These stories expose the terrifying fragility of perception, the cost of misinterpretation, and how the truth—especially when it comes to death—can be both stranger and more brutal than fiction.
A parrot's gas inhalation habit led to fatal carbon monoxide poisoning in a woman's locked bedroom, proving even pets can be deadly.
A doctor's premonition of dying in a car crash was accurate—but the location was wrong; she died in her own car days after canceling a trip.
A woman buried alive due to a misdiagnosed fever was revived by grave robbers cutting off her finger, causing her husband to die of shock upon seeing her.
Misinterpreting a premonition can be as dangerous as ignoring it—Linda Gowdy’s cancellation saved her life, but her relationship paid the price.
Grave robbers in 18th-century Ireland targeted graves for gold rings, leading to a woman being dug up and revived—only to cause her husband’s death.
…and 3 more takeaways available in PodZeus
A Bad Habit: The Parrot That Killed Her
“The parrot survived because he was able to make his way over to the door and breathe in that fresh air.”
The Cancelled Vacation: A Premonition That Was Right
“The premonition she had was right. She did die in a car. The location was just wrong.”
The Ring: Buried Alive and Revived
“When John opened the door and he saw his wife standing there covered in dirt and missing a finger and looking horrible, he was so shocked and so scared that he had a heart attack and he actually died.”
“When John opened the door and he saw his wife standing there covered in dirt and missing a finger and looking horrible, he was so shocked and so scared that he had a heart attack and he actually died.”
“Meaning, the premonition she had was right. She did die in a car. The location was just wrong.”
“Alice would die from inhaling the gas, but the parrot survived because he was able to make his way over to the door and breathe in that fresh air.”
Host
Polly
other
Linda Gowdy
person
Alice Knott
person
Marjorie McCall
person
John McCall
person
MrBallen
person
Tim Stryker
person
Shankill Cemetery
place
Evan Allen
person
Kate Murdoch
person
Deadly Plans
30m • 6/11/2026
Teke Teke | Campfire Stories with MrBallen
26m • 6/12/2026
Closing Time (PODCAST EXCLUSIVE EPISODE)
37m • 6/1/2026
Killer Profile (PODCAST EXCLUSIVE EPISODE)
39m • 6/15/2026
Start discovering podcast insights today
Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.
No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime

