Deadly Plans

MrBallen Podcast: Strange, Dark & Mysterious Stories30mJune 11, 2026
AI-Generated Summary

In a chilling tale of obsession and delusion, a reverend named John Carmichael, convinced that a local drunk named Gideon Browning possessed supernatural powers of mind control, believed he was being hypnotized during a fateful ride together. What began as a series of strange coincidences—Gideon appearing everywhere—escalated into a nightmarish journey where Carmichael, in a state of paranoid delusion, followed Gideon’s commands, bought him a hatchet, and ultimately murdered him in his own church. After dismembering and burning Gideon’s body, Carmichael donned his clothes and fled 500 miles away, assuming a new identity as 'John Elder' to hide. He was found dead in a boarding house outhouse, having slit his own throat, leaving behind a bloodstained confession that revealed his belief in Gideon’s hypnotic powers. The story, rooted in real events, exposes how unchecked mental illness and societal neglect can lead to unimaginable violence. Meanwhile, in a separate but equally disturbing story, David File, the last tenant in a condemned English apartment complex, rigged a chainsaw to his neck in a final protest against eviction—only to die by his own hand, ensuring his death became a headline but not a change in policy.

Key Takeaways
1

Belief in supernatural mind control can lead to fatal delusions, even when no actual hypnosis occurs.

2

David File's suicide by chainsaw trap was a final protest against eviction, not a random act of violence.

3

Reverend Carmichael killed Gideon Browning in self-defense based on a delusional belief in hypnotic powers.

4

The murderer disguised himself as the victim, fleeing 500 miles under a false identity.

5

A bloodstained confession was found on the killer’s body, proving his belief in the delusion.

…and 3 more takeaways available in PodZeus

Chapters
0:00
2 min

Introduction to Two Disturbing True Stories

MrBallen introduces today's episode featuring two true stories of extreme human behavior: one about a man who rigged a chainsaw to his neck in protest, and another about a reverend who murdered a man he believed was hypnotizing him.

1:40
4 min

The Last Tenant: David File's Final Protest

He basically timed it so that shortly after getting in position, the timer would go off, it would cut his head off, and then presumably authorities would look inside the apartment and see what, in David's mind, they were responsible for. His death.

Highlight
5:50
7 min

The Good Reverend: A Delusion of Hypnosis

The reverend believed he was hypnotized. And so he just kind of began going along with anything Gideon wanted.

Highlight
12:30
7 min

The Murder and the Disguise

After killing Gideon, Carmichael dismembered and burned his body, then stole his clothes and fled 500 miles away, assuming a new identity as 'John Elder' to evade detection.

19:10
8 min

The Confession and the End

It was the confession of Reverend Carmichael who genuinely believed Gideon had hypnotized him and had all these special powers. And he basically was acting in self-defense.

Highlight
High-Impact Quotes
And he basically timed it so that shortly after getting in position, the timer would go off, it would cut his head off, and then presumably authorities would look inside the apartment and see what, in David's mind, they were responsible for. His death.
MrBallen6:54
Now, granted, it was the confession of Reverend Carmichael who genuinely believed Gideon had hypnotized him and had all these special powers. And he basically was acting in self -defense.
MrBallen27:25
And so at this point, the reverend actually believed he was hypnotized. And so he just kind of began going along with anything Gideon wanted.
MrBallen25:06
Speakers

Host

MrBallen
Topics Discussed
true crime95%mental health delusion90%suicide protest85%historical murder mystery80%hypnosis belief75%identity theft70%eviction protest65%cold case60%
People & Brands

John Carmichael

person

18xNeutral

Gideon Browning

person

15xNeutral

MrBallen

person

15xNeutral

David File

person

12xNeutral

Rattle Run Church

organization

8xNeutral

Atlantic Housing

organization

6xNeutral

Miranda Hughes

person

4xNeutral

Columbus

place

3xNeutral

Bishopstoke

place

2xNeutral

Evan Allen

person

1xNeutral

Start discovering podcast insights today

Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.

No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime